Products
Glide CMS image
Glide CMS arrow
The powerful intuitive headless CMS for busy content and editorial teams, bursting with features and sector insight. MACH architecture gives you business freedom.
Glide Go image
Glide Go arrow
Enterprise power at start-up speed. Glide Go is a pre-configured deployment of Glide CMS with hosting and front-end problems solved.
Glide Nexa image
Glide Nexa arrow
Audience authentication, entitlements, and preference management in one system designed for publishers and content businesses.
For your sector
Media & Entertainment
arrow
Built for any content to thrive, whoever it's for. Get your content out faster and do more with it.
Sports & Gaming
arrow
Bring fans closer to their passions and deliver unrivalled audience experiences wherever they are.
Publishing
arrow
Tailored to the unique needs of publishing so you can fully focus on audiences and content success.
For your role
Technology
arrow
Unlock resources and budget with low-code & no-code solutions to do so much more.
Editorial & Content
arrow
Make content of higher quality quicker, and target it with pinpoint accuracy at the right audiences.
Developers
arrow
MACH architecture lets you kickstart development, leveraging vast native functionality and top-tier support.
Commercial & Marketing
arrow
Speedrun ideas into products, accelerate ROI, convert interest, and own the conversation.
Technology Partners
AWS image
AWS
arrow
Getty Images image
Getty Images
arrow
Brightcove image
Brightcove
arrow
Poool image
Poool
arrow
Solution Partners
Endava image
Endava
arrow
The App Lab image
The App Lab
arrow
Code Store image
Code Store
arrow
Polemic Digital image
Polemic Digital
arrow
Resources
Developer Experience
arrow
Find out more how to work with Glide headless CMS, Glide Go, and Glide Nexa identity management
Customer Support
arrow
Learn more about unrivalled customer support from team Glide
Documentation
arrow
User and Technical documentation for the Glide Publishing Platform, Glide Go, and Glide Nexa
Newsroom
News arrow
Comment arrow
Newsletter arrow

Is a defensive Google worse for the publishing industry?

As Google feels the need to justify itself more loudly than ever on multiple fronts, should we just accept they long ago forgot the essence of their goal to "organise the world’s information and make it universally accessible and useful"?

by  Rob Corbidge
14:23, 28 July 2022
Google on the defensive

Speculation about the slow death of the quality of Google Search still seems largely in contradiction to the rude corporate health of Big G itself. Even as it announced a slow in growth last week, the numbers are still huge: $69.69 billion in second quarter revenue alone, with net income at $16 billion. YouTube alone saw $7.3 billion in advertising revenue in that period.

From the macro to the micro. The Corbidge Household Management Acquisition Company was searching for advice on bakeware last week. The decision at hand concerned the purchase of either a metal cake tin, or a silicone cake mould. Which one was most suitable for the project being planned?

A straight Google search was not a pointless exercise, yielding three fairly good top results, only one of which was trying to affiliate-sell me stuff. Then we had six ok-ish results, and a marketing blog for a company selling silicone bakeware as the tenth result. We got to page five before there fully ceased to be much in any result of relevance to a decision, rather than a purchase, but it had got patchy before that.

Personally, not enough information for a risky cake bake to get the greenlight.

Appending "reddit" to the same search proved much more fruitful. Two pages of solid results, across a number of the site's specialist discussion boards, each response written by a human, and upvoted for relevancy by other humans. 

With such a wealth of curated information and discussion I felt more than able to make a decision, and the cake bake was back on. There may have been some clever marketeer inserting links here and there among the comments on those results, but it's hard - Reddit moderators are a pretty zealous bunch.

The sweet irony here is that searching Reddit posts is much easier if you use Google: Reddit's own search is pretty awful. Search company better at the actual mechanics of search than social forum company at search? What a surprise. But at content that's been curated properly - Reddit wins.

Google does not provide the best search experience. 

Google is on the defensive across a wide range of fronts, so the perception that the quality of search is declining is an important one. Search is their very core, even as they relentlessly diversify into other market areas. 

So we see Google saying things such as "on average over the past four years, 80 percent of searches on Google haven’t had any ads at the top of search results." . If they'd said that back in 2004, you'd read it one way, in 2022, you read it quite another.

Anyway what does this have to do with our collective industry relationship with how people use the internet? 

A defensive Google is now handing money over to publishers around the globe. The money is welcome of course, but it's only treating the bite while ignoring the gargantuan mosquito. It's also defensive money. We can all see that. Yet the actions of a defensive Google are stifling innovation as the business largely fails to innovate itself. One can view it that Google now is the status quo and whatever money it disburses is serving the ends of reinforcing the status quo more than it is helping end it. Everyone in publishing knows that's not a good thing, deep down.  

The consumer is mostly (although not totally) apathetic to this I believe, even as the body politic has woken up to it. On an individual level, I see many friends from the hybrid tech/publishing slot I occupy turning to other options. One of my machines uses only DuckDuckGo on MS Edge as an experiment in trying to escape Google's shadow to see what difference there is. The quality of our search lives has not particularly declined.

For now, it's important to remember that Google is the first such business of its kind and anything that it wishes you to believe is "systemic" is no such thing, it's merely where we are now.

There is the comforting thought, that, however hard you think about it, the future tends to not be as expected.

Latest articles

article listing image
The inside story of the runaway elephant in the room
arrow button
article listing image
How a picture of gold can seem worth more than the gold itself
arrow button
article listing image
Universal findings can cause local problems
arrow button

Ready to get started?

No matter where you are on your CMS journey, we're here to help. Want more info or to see Glide Publishing Platform in action? We got you.

Book a demo