arrow Products
Glide CMS image Glide CMS image
Glide CMS arrow
The powerful intuitive headless CMS for busy content and editorial teams, bursting with features and sector insight. MACH architecture gives you business freedom.
Glide Go image Glide Go image
Glide Go arrow
Enterprise power at start-up speed. Glide Go is a pre-configured deployment of Glide CMS with hosting and front-end problems solved.
Glide Nexa image Glide Nexa image
Glide Nexa arrow
Audience authentication, entitlements, and preference management in one system designed for publishers and content businesses.
For your sector arrow arrow
Media & Entertainment
arrow arrow
Built for any content to thrive, whomever it's for. Get content out faster and do more with it.
Sports & Gaming
arrow arrow
Bring fans closer to their passions and deliver unrivalled audience experiences wherever they are.
Publishing
arrow arrow
Tailored to the unique needs of publishing so you can fully focus on audiences and content success.
For your role arrow arrow
Technology
arrow arrow
Unlock resources and budget with low-code & no-code solutions to do so much more.
Editorial & Content
arrow arrow
Make content of higher quality quicker, and target it with pinpoint accuracy at the right audiences.
Developers
arrow arrow
MACH architecture lets you kickstart development, leveraging vast native functionality and top-tier support.
Commercial & Marketing
arrow arrow
Speedrun ideas into products, accelerate ROI, convert interest, and own the conversation.
Technology Partners arrow arrow
Explore Glide's world-class technology partners and integrations.
Solution Partners arrow arrow
For workflow guidance, SEO, digital transformation, data & analytics, and design, tap into Glide's solution partners and sector experts.
Industry Insights arrow arrow
News
arrow arrow
News from inside our world, about Glide Publishing Platform, our customers, and other cool things.
Comment
arrow arrow
Insight and comment about the things which make content and publishing better - or sometimes worse.
Expert Guides
arrow arrow
Essential insights and helpful resources from industry veterans, and your gateway to CMS and Glide mastery.
Newsletter
arrow arrow
The Content Aware weekly newsletter, with news and comment every Thursday.
Knowledge arrow arrow
Customer Support
arrow arrow
Learn more about the unrivalled customer support from the team at Glide.
Documentation
arrow arrow
User Guides and Technical Documentation for Glide Publishing Platform headless CMS, Glide Go, and Glide Nexa.
Developer Experience
arrow arrow
Learn more about using Glide headless CMS, Glide Go, and Glide Nexa identity management.

Bots faking it as people is a fact of modern life - but is it art?

Computer says "This is not art; no beauty, no skill, no emotional depth, it is merely a statement devoid of any artistic merit...no!"

by Rob Corbidge
Published: 12:29, 26 September 2024
AI is now reviewing art while wearing the mask of a human - is it art or life?

Criticism, or in the less biting modern parlance, reviewing, is one of those areas of media competence that still pulls in the eyeballs. 

One of my earliest memorable tasks in media did not involve learning how to report, but instead using my young legs and best suit to act an usher at the funeral of Dilys Powell, film critic for The Sunday Times, who wrote for the newspaper for 50 years. 

She was held in such great esteem by both the newspaper and the wider cultural community that her funeral was attended by many of the great and good, and as a testament to a life well lived it was a lesson for me.

Yet as well as bringing fresh ideas, attitude and even language to the world of film criticism, Powell also clearly made a contribution to that all-important item - the newspaper's bottom line. The same could be said of fellow film critic Pauline Kael, on the other side of the Atlantic. 

A good critic, skilled in their delivery, confident in their cultural authority and with clear and well articulated ideas, remains a draw for audiences across many a milieu. 

One of the most obvious developments in the contemporary period is how the number of public relations operatives has increased while the number of journalists shrunk, leading to those who must navigate these publicity gatekeepers being branded "access media" by those who don't engage with them and who instead use the democratising nature of the technology platforms to disseminate their own critical reviews.  

Whatever the case, criticism remains a popular content form across numerous areas of human cultural endeavour, from music to food.

This week then brought the unexpected news that AI is being utilised to bring one of Britain's most famous art critics back to life. Brian Sewell wrote for the London Evening Standard for many decades, and was known for his unforgiving views on many artists and their work.

He was "a man intent on keeping his Christmas card list nice and short" as one contemporary put it. Yet, as infuriating as many found his views, at least an equal number revelled in them, and enjoyed his intelligent and engaging writing, as well as his carefully modulated spoken persona on broadcast media.

He is to be brought back for another, single appearance, despite having died in 2015. The Evening Standard has confirmed that "A.I. Sewell" is to review The National Gallery’s latest Vincent van Gogh exhibition, Van Gogh: Poets and Lovers, as the once-daily publication relaunches as a weekly this week. According to the Standard's chief executive Paul Kanareck, the idea is "a one-off intended to provoke discussion about AI and journalism". 

So it is, of course, a stunt being undertaken for the publicity, an aim which we have clearly fulfilled by writing about it.

The reaction to the news that a dead person is doing journalism among such people that hear "AI" and "job losses" in the same thought is understandable, given what we are told, ad nauseam, about the capabilities of the technology. 

Many too questioned the legality of it, though the Standard's quick assertion that "the estate are delighted" shows they have done their homework: the recent EU AI Act - not enforced yet but likely to become a model for others bringing their own legislation to fruit - does not allow writers to be 'cloned' without their personal approval, or in cases where the author is dead, of their estate. 

I feel however that such a reaction is missing a more important point.

There's no doubt that a model trained on the words of Brian Sewell will be able to produce writing that is a fairly close simulacrum of his work. It will be working on fairly safe ground with a Van Gogh exhibition: although Sewell liked to look forwards as much as back, he admired the Dutch artist.

Yet, other than cramming the ideas "journalism" and "AI" into the same content can and bashing the lid shut with a heavy production hammer, this project adds nothing to the canon of Sewell's work, and nothing to the volumes of work written about Van Gogh.

It isn't Sewell, it's a generic pattern of Sewell, of interest in the same way an impressionist is for how similar to their subject they might sound, and can add no value to the brand that was the man. It has value only as a gimmick, and really isn't much of a showcase for AI. This is not a path for the longevity of our industry.

If you take a read of Pauline Kale's wiki entry, you'll learn that she started on the path to critical fame after a magazine owner "overheard Kael arguing about films in a coffee shop with a friend".

There's another Sewell out there for sure waiting to be found by one means or another, we really don't need to reanimate the dead one, as amusing as he would have probably found it. 

Latest articles

AI legislation is coming - and some of it might even be good
The race to write the laws which will make or break AI
arrow button
a newsroom full of journalists. an evil robot burglar looking like a prisoner holding a sack full of money with money spilling out of it
Platforms vs Publishers: The Forever War
arrow button
Evil robot lawyer in a full courtroom
Big Tech ain't quite what it says it is
arrow button

Ready to get started?

No matter where you are on your CMS journey, we're here to help. Want more info or to see Glide Publishing Platform in action? We got you.

Book a demo