Ready to get started?
No matter where you are on your CMS journey, we're here to help. Want more info or to see Glide Publishing Platform in action? We got you.
Book a demoJudgement in the copyright case of all copyright cases is looming. Will we finally get a workable notion of what "fair use" is in the LLM age?

Litigation, not legislation, will steer the immediate course of the wider relationships between publishers and those who seek to use their proprietary content for the purposes of AI. The other truth is that this litigation will largely occur in US courts, as the United States is the domicile of the vast majority of the companies involved in AI and the legal landscape there has a more fundamental effect on their actual behaviour than any foreign court.
That being the situation, many of us on this side of the Atlantic have, of recent years, had to familiarise ourselves with the American legal concept of "fair use" for copyrighted works, mostly in my case by reading the case law cited in the current wave of copyright litigation. On that basis alone and with all the precision my non-lawyerly mind can muster, I can tell you that "fair use" is a pretty delicate legal concept. Not a bad one, but very much dependent on exact circumstance when put to the test of a court, as proved in the recent Reuters case.
That test is about to be made in a humdinger of a case being heard in New York soon, a case that, crucially, will be heard by a judge alone, without a jury. In Re: OpenAI, Inc. Copyright Infringement Litigation both OpenAI and Microsoft will hear whether using content such as news articles, books and any other copyrighted material without permission for the purposes of training their LLMs is indeed "fair use".
What makes this case significant, is, notwithstanding the two original and important copyright actions that sit at the heart of it, the fact that earlier this month US District Judge Sidney Stein, who is hearing the case, allowed 56 amicus briefs to be filed regarding it. These amicus briefs allow for interested parties not directly involved in the case to make their opinions and relevant information known to the court.
Fifty-six is a lot of interest for one case, admittedly a case that is actually a combination of legal actions of which two are most of note. The first of those is The Authors Guild case against OpenAI, filed in September 2023, contending that OpenAI used the copyrighted works of authors to feed its LLM training pipeline. Names sitting behind The Authors Guild action include writers such as George R.R. Martin, Jonathan Franzen, Stacy Schiff, John Grisham and many more. Quite the summer reading liist.
The second case involves The New York Times' action against both Microsoft and OpenAI over "the unlawful use of NYT's work to create artificial intelligence products". You can say what you want about the NYT's own commercial strategy, but they always fight for what is theirs.
Of those 56 parties wishing to make their views known to Judge Stein, who will sit in the US District Court for the Southern District of New York - Manhattan in other words - 27 are on the side of the creators, while 18 are on the side of the AI companies. The remainder are filed undeclared in their preference.
We know this thanks to an excellent piece of data journalism (which did use some AI) by Tech Policy Press, and we urge you to look at their full breakdown here as each one of the amicus filings is worth a read.
Together, they amply illustrate both sides of the copyright war and that no side can assume a slam dunk, and highlight some positions which on the face of it may not be expected.
In there, you will find such bodies as the Electronic Frontier Foundation, stalwart defenders of digital privacy, arguing for the side of AI companies, in saying that "Plaintiffs are asking the Court to [...] rewrite copyright law to include a lawful acquisition requirement that finds no basis in statute or case law; and to tilt the fair use analysis against the developer of a general-purpose tool if that tool might be used to create potentially competing non-infringing works."
On the pro-creator side, by way of example, the influential US local media lobbying group America's Newspapers argue that "If the wholesale copying at issue here is fair use, local publishers will be left in an impossible position: unable to stop AI companies from using their work and unable to demand payment when they do."
A quick human-powered sentiment analysis of the filings reveals the rough split. On the AI defendants’ side, the claims are more technical, and more abstract. On the creator plaintiffs’ side, the language is more of creativity and commerce.
At the heart of Judge Stein's deliberations will be if AI use of copyrighted material was transformative, and whether or not the outputs or products created with it were competing against those provided by the creators.
Furthermore, to my mind, is an even deeper question of whether or not law created to manage human operations is suited to an age of autonomous-like machine operations. By way of illustrating this, I example the Andy Warhol "Prince photo" fair use case from 2023 being cited in arguments about transformation and AI.
This was a case so particular in nature, and involving very specific questions of actual art - which many would think is defined by its inability to be defined in a single way - that leaning on it to justify an AI-era consumption model of words, images, thoughts, and creative effort, is like relying on one person's anecdote about tickling an angry cat behind its ear as a survival guide in a lion enclosure.
The sheer scale and speed of AI systems is something still quite new, and their appetite for content is like nothing we've ever seen before.
I hope Judge Stein can think both fast and slow at the same time.
No matter where you are on your CMS journey, we're here to help. Want more info or to see Glide Publishing Platform in action? We got you.
Book a demo